I've never been there but when we were in Vermont, everyone seemed unanimous that Craftsbury was the best. Glad you had such a perfect day! :)
It was a pretty impressive place! But still had a very nice, homey feel to it. Most of the people in the place I was staying were there from Craftsbury, and they run a shuttle between the two places so that if you want, you can ski from the lodge back to Craftsbury with a net downhill of 1000 feet. I didn't get a chance to try it but it sounded fun!